• Home
  • Our story
  • Our people
  • Myth busters
  • Act now
  • Visit us
  • Blog
Campaign Against Canned Hunting (CACH)

The telling comparison

9/25/2015

2 Comments

 
Picture


Game Farming and wildlife sanctuary – the telling comparison.

Because hunting involves cruelty, killing and adverse impacts upon biodiversity, you’d expect hunting to be heavily regulated and monitored.   And you’d expect animal protection to be lightly regulated, to encourage public participation.

But this is South Africa, where the hunting fraternity controls conservation.

To start a hunting farm you would need:

1.  A Certificate of Adequate Enclosure.
This confirms that his perimeter fence is strong and high enough and Presto!  all regulations vanish like smoke.  No need to apply for any re-zoning, or obtain EIAs, or file complex business or management plans, or be restricted by hunting seasons; the landowner is free to do what he likes with his ‘alternative livestock.’ Indeed,  he can turn the land in to a battlefield, like the infamous driven hunt at Alldays in Limpopo. See this illustrated report on the Alldays hunt, showing how hunting is to conservation what pornography is to art.

https://www.thedodo.com/hunters-hide-their-faces-1347803434.html?utm_source=HuffPo&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pubexchange_facebook

Now compare the regulatory burden on wildlife sanctuaries or rehab centres.

To start a Wildlife Sanctuary you would need:

1.     Re-zoning application is required, for animal rescue
A one-size-fits-all re-zoning application means that the mind-numbing requirements designed for large scale developments such as a new golf course complex or a five star ten story hotel all have to be met by the poor wildlife rehabber.

Here is just one small extract from the re-zoning application form:

5.1.1 Physical characteristics of the property

The expected impact of the proposed land use change and any change to the physical characteristics , must be discussed. The physical characteristics include topography , geological formations , soil properties and depth of underlying rock formations , microclimate , vegetation ( eg plants) , floodplains and flood lines , water tables , fountains , drainage , unique ecological habitats and sensitive areas , existing filled areas and quarrying ,  and so on.


Really!!??  All this – and much, much more - just to rescue a bundle of fur or feathers??
(29th Sept.  Since posting this blog we have been notified by the Department of Planning that upon reconsideration we shall not have to apply to rezone the property.)

2.      An E.I.A. (environmental impact assessment) 
For which yet another expensive consultant is required.  An EIA can only be done by a registered qualified EIA practitioner, and the whole process can take months, and cost tens of thousands of Rands.
3.      Formal standard operating procedures (SOPs)
For every aspect of the rehab process; use of vehicles, use of equipment, cleaning, etc .etc – all of which must be signed by staff and volunteers. The detail required is so overwhelming that even where to park the car at night must be included in the SOP!
4.      Expensive and unnecessarily high and strong fences
For enclosures, even those designed to hold small, harmless animals.
5.      Explain mission and vision, species and number of animals kept
(how on earth to know this in advance?)
6.  How you are going to meet the physiological, physical and psychological needs of the animals
(We do not have them yet so how do we know.)
7.      Transport facilities
8.      Veterinary Facilites
9.      Fire Management Plan
10.    Personnel training
11.    Liability Insurance for millions
12.    Escape plans
13.    Exist Strategies
14.    Letters of support from all neighbours
15.  Essay on how the centre will add value to conservation, research, education
(but you are not allowed to have children to the centre)
16.    Risk Assessment
17.    Ecological impacts
18.    Oh and membership of PAAZAB
(Logic?? PAAZAB is a zoo association. Why on earth should a rehabber be forced to join a Zoo association?  Zoos exist for human entertainment; the rehabber has no interest in human entertainment.   Some of PAAZAB’s rules, such as the requirement to be open to the public at all times, are bizarrely inappropriate to a rehab centre, which is closed to the public at all times.)

The point is this: not only are these excessive bureaucratic obstacles discouraging people from exercising their legal right to participate in wildlife management, but the fact that none of these onerous obligations are imposed upon game hunting farms boggles the mind. 

Is this burdensome bureaucracy really necessary for conservation purposes?
·     If these onerous bureaucratic demands were really important, then they would apply to game farming and the hunting industry – much more so because hunting impacts the environment far more than rescuing and rehabbing orphaned and injured wildlife. Despite the anti-conservation antics of an out-of-control hunting fraternity, such as cross-breeding mutant freaks for hunting trophies, or turning the land in to a battlefield like the driven hunt at Alldays in Lipopo, no EIAs are required. 

·       In the conservation sub-culture, ‘welfare’ of animals is almost a swear word.  There is open hostility to the whole idea of animal welfare, and anyone who speaks out against cruelty to wildlife is pejoratively labelled a ‘greenie,’ a ‘rightist’, a ‘radical’ and ‘an‘extremist.’ 

·    In seeking to control every aspect of sanctuary/rehab activity, the conservation authorities are acting ultra vires ie outside their legal powers.  In short, illegally. The Supreme Court of Appeal decided in the Predator Breeders case that breeding lions for canned hunting or other human entertainment fell outside the authority of conservationists – because the lions would never be released back to the wild . So, on the same basis, a sanctuary cannot be regulated by conservation structures, because sanctuary animals will never be released.

So why are conservationists so obsessed with controlling every aspect of animal welfare facilities when they have no legal right to do so?  Watch this space next month and learn about regulatory capture.

2 Comments

All grown up

9/24/2015

5 Comments

 
We thank Jade again for sending us news of the cubs, Yame & George. The pictures are wonderful and for those we thank Shaun Fessey and Luise Dittombee.  I know that you all love the reports as much as I do.  Over to Jade.

Picture
Hi Bev

I hope this finds you well. Its that time again, for a little update on the adventures of George and Yame.

The time has finally come for George’s trip to the vet. We will be taking him in tomorrow for new radiographs, and an MRI. Yame will be going with to keep him company as he will need to spend a few days there. These procedures will give us a good idea of what is going on with his bones now, and will light the way forward in terms of a treatment plan (to reverse the severe effects of poor diet when he was a young cub). Yame is in perfect health, and the consequences of poor diet that plague George seem to be non-existent in him now. As Im sure you can see from their pictures, Yame is much bigger, and more muscular than George. It continues to be a balancing act with George, and the amount of physical activity we do with him. A little is good to build muscle which can support the bones, etc… but too much and he starts to hurt a little.
Picture
George
Picture
Yame
The new growth around the reserve continues to attract a wide variety of herbivores. This has been the highlight for George and Yame as they go on their enrichment walks. Just yesterday they exhibited the perfect hunting traits of wild lions. Both went into a low stalk when they saw a herd of wildebeest on the opposite hillside. They broke cover very early, and began to chase them… without success, but they sure did try! Nobody is immune, and we often turn to find Yame stalking us as well, just like wild lions would stalk and pounce on their siblings, and other pride members. He gets the most ridiculous, playful expression seconds before, which you will see in one of his pictures  J
Picture
Yame
Picture
Yame
We have started introducing other things into their weekly routines as well now to keep them mentally stimulated. For example, they occasionally get whole carcasses to eat (depending on what we have been given) which they love. They don’t get it everyday, but it’s a treat to watch them when they do. They both instinctively grab the animal in a suffocation bite at the neck, or over the muzzle which just proves again that this isn’t something that needs to be taught to a lion. We have also been experimenting with a variety of new scents which we spray in their enclosure (cinnamon, citrus, mint, etc. George really loves the mint, while Yame doesn’t seem too interested…yet). 
Picture
George
Picture
Yame
It is amazing to look back at pictures of the boys when they first arrived, and see how much they’ve changed, and grown in the past year. They have really flourished in their new home, and will continue to do so with the help of so many people around the world who continue to spread the word about the horrible industry that they were once a part of. I hope that you enjoy the photos, compliments of Shaun Fessey, and Luise Dittombee.

Regards,
Jade
Picture
Picture
George
Picture
5 Comments

    Newsletter

    Archives

    August 2022
    January 2022
    July 2021
    May 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    May 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

Animal advocacy courses are offered here:

    Subscribe to our newsletter:

Submit
PUBLIC BENEFIT NUMBER: PB0930030402        |        REG. NUMBER: 2006/036885/08   
   CACH:  P.O. BOX 54 LADISMITH 6655 SOUTH AFRICA     |     MOBILE/CELL/WHATSAPP:  +27 (0) 82 9675808
.